03 · The Detour

How wood ash made a 1796 cookie rise

The cookie that ran on wood ash · No. 002 · · About 7 min read

VerifiedClaimAnalysisTaste

Bookmarks need a Mind Club sign-in. How sign-in works

Four recipes in Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery call for pearl ash, a refined wood ash that did the job baking powder does now. Here’s how a byproduct of the fireplace got into the gingerbread, and why it left.

“two tea spoons pearl ash” From the ingredient list of “Cookies,” American Cookery, Hartford, 1796.

A book printed in Hartford in 1796 has a recipe called “Cookies.” Its ingredient list includes “two tea spoons pearl ash.” Verified

The book is American Cookery, printed by Hudson & Goodwin “for the author,” and its title page credits Amelia Simmons, “AN AMERICAN ORPHAN.” Verified Connecticut History, a CTHumanities project, calls it “widely accepted as the first cookbook written by an American.” Claim American Heritage draws the line more tightly: cookbooks had been printed in America before, but this was the first book of American recipes by an American author. Claim

That “first” is how most people meet the book. The better story is the pearl ash in the cookies.

Simmons uses pearl ash in four recipes: Cookies, Another Christmas Cookey, Molasses Gingerbread, and Gingerbread Cakes, or butter and sugar Gingerbread. Verified Pearl ash is a refined form of potash, and potash is made from wood ash. Claim (Harold McGee, On Food and Cooking) So a cookie in a 1796 book was raised with something that started out in a fire.

Rising, the slow way

Before chemical leaveners, a cake rose on yeast or on muscle. Writing in American Heritage in 1981, Martha C. Brown listed what the book otherwise leans on: “eggs and air whipped in by the cook, spirits, or homemade liquid yeast.” Claim Simmons’s yeast was emptins, which Brown describes as “a mixture of hops and the dregs of beer or cider casks.” Claim

Yeast is patient. Jessica Carbone of the National Museum of American History told Smithsonian magazine that yeast baking meant “upwards of 12 hours of rising, usually more like 24 hours.” Claim Pearl ash, by contrast, “produced carbon dioxide very quickly,” according to a Johnson & Wales baking science text. Claim

That’s the whole appeal. A gingerbread that doesn’t need a day’s notice. Analysis

From the hearth to the barrel

Making pearl ash was heavy, hot work. Benjamin C. Pykles lays out the process in BYU Studies. Hardwood ashes were soaked with water, and the “highly caustic lye” was drained off. Claim The lye was boiled down in iron kettles to a dark residue called black salts. Heated further, the salts fused into potash. Potash “could be further refined in a specialized oven to produce a product known as pearlash.” Claim

So the sequence runs wood, ash, lye, black salts, potash, pearl ash. Each step costs more fire. Analysis

What comes out is “mostly alkaline potassium carbonate,” McGee writes. Claim “Alkaline” means it’s a base, the chemical opposite of an acid, and that turns out to matter a great deal for the cookie. Analysis

The kitchen was never pearl ash’s main customer. Potash went into soap, glass and textiles. Claim (American Heritage; Smithsonian’s Lemelson Center) It was also an export. A table in the same BYU Studies article shows Britain importing 10 tons of potash and pearl ash from North America in 1760, out of 2,424 tons in all. By 1811 the figure was 6,595 tons of 8,927, or 74%. Claim The two years come from two different economic histories, which the table sets side by side, so read the jump as a direction, not a precise multiple. Analysis

The new country noticed. The Smithsonian’s Lemelson Center records that the first U.S. patent, issued to Samuel Hopkins on July 31, 1790, covered “a new method of making potash and pearl ash.” Claim Nobody filed it under dessert.

Why it lifts a dough

Here’s the machine. A Yale teaching unit puts it in one line: pearl ash “reacts with acids in doughs to generate carbon dioxide gas.” Claim McGee says much the same. Claim The gas makes bubbles, and the oven sets the dough around them. Analysis

The base needs an acid partner. The Yale unit lists “yogurt, sour milk, buttermilk and molasses” as acidic ingredients that a leavener like baking soda can react with. Claim

Look at Simmons’s four recipes with that in mind. In each one the pearl ash goes in dissolved in a liquid: milk, cream or water. Verified (our description, not her wording) One of the four has molasses in its name and in its list. Verified That recipe brings its own acid. Analysis For the cookies made with milk, the book doesn’t say whether the milk had soured, so how well they rose is something the text can’t tell us. Analysis

The catch

Pearl ash had problems, and the sources agree on them. It “tends to leave a bitter residue,” Brown writes. Claim Smithsonian calls it “difficult to make, caustic and often smelly.” Claim The Johnson & Wales text says it “smelled terrible.” Claim

The food historian Sarah Lohman, who made pearl ash cookies for her blog, reported “a horrible, alkaline bitterness” and suspected heavy spice was how gingerbread hid it. Claim Four recipes, two of them gingerbread. The pattern fits her guess, though four is a small sample. Analysis

The acid was the other weak link. Sour milk was cheap, Smithsonian notes, but “it was hard to control how acidic the sour milk actually was.” Claim Too little acid, and the leftover base flavors the cake. Analysis

There’s also a wrinkle in the timeline. Brown writes that neither pearl ash nor the other chemical leaveners that became baking powders “are usually thought to have been used in cooking before 1830,” which would put Simmons, “and presumably other American cooks,” well ahead of their time. Claim

What replaced it

The successors arrived in steps. First came saleratus, from the New Latin sal aeratus, “aerated salt,” a leavener of potassium or sodium bicarbonate. Merriam-Webster dates the word in that sense to 1834. Claim

WyoHistory.org says shops had sold saleratus only since about 1840, and that emigrants on the overland trails scraped it from dry lake beds near Independence Rock. Claim Bread made with it sometimes came out “a faint green.” Claim

Baking soda followed, dated by Smithsonian to 1846. Claim It still needed an acid from the cook. Baking powder solved that by packing the base and the acid together, so the bubbles wait for water: a Library of Congress teachers’ blog describes it as chemicals that “produce carbon-dioxide bubbles through an acid-base reaction.” Claim

Who made it first depends on whom you ask. Smithsonian credits the English chemist Alfred Bird in the late 1840s and says Eben Norton Horsford patented “the first modern baking powder,” dating the patent to 1856. Claim A 1930 U.S. Department of Agriculture circular says “the first formulas for baking powder were developed in the United States in the year 1850,” when Preston & Merrill of Boston sold one. Claim Two “firsts,” two definitions. Analysis

Pearl ash, Brown writes, “was eventually discarded in the process of perfecting baking powders.” Claim

The pie on the next page

Thanksgiving falls on November 26 this year. Verified American Cookery has two entries headed “Pompkin.” Verified One calls for “mace, nutmeg and ginger”; the other, “molasses, allspice and ginger.” Verified Neither uses pearl ash. Verified The pie never needed to rise. Analysis

Connecticut History says the book was reprinted 13 times and that only four copies of the Hartford first edition are known today. Claim The text, though, is free to read online (see Try).

Back to “Cookies” and its “two tea spoons pearl ash.” The can of baking powder in your cupboard does the same job, with the acid already inside and the fire already far away. Simmons had to bring the acid herself. And the ash.

Start here

The Project Gutenberg text of American Cookery. Search “pearl ash,” then read the two “Pompkin” entries. Taste the four recipe titles and the ingredient lines show the whole story in a few minutes, with no translation needed.

How we found it

The far shelf, national cookbook collections; the Library of Congress pages wouldn’t open, so we went to the Project Gutenberg text and Connecticut History, then to the chemistry and trade sources.

Sources Project Gutenberg, American Cookery (10.30.2026) · Connecticut History, CTHumanities (11.21.2021) · American Heritage (Aug./Sept. 1981) · BYU Studies 41, no. 1 · Smithsonian Lemelson Center (10.30.2026) · Harold McGee, On Food and Cooking (2004) · Yale National Initiative (2017) · Johnson & Wales University pressbook (10.30.2026) · Smithsonian magazine (10.30.2026) · Library of Congress teachers’ blog (11.2021) · USDA Circular 138 (11.1930) · Merriam-Webster (10.30.2026) · WyoHistory.org (03.31.2016) · Four Pounds Flour (05.23.2012)